Act I
| Clara | Mackenzie McCormick |
| The Nutcracker |
Eliezer Rabello Stephen Jacobsen (Battle Scene) |
| Clara’s Best Friends |
Timmerie Millington Brianna Tait |
| Fritz | Zachary Lynch (alternate: Max Cibelli) |
| Herr Drosselmeyer | Jim Ferranti (alternate: Tom Zepko) |
| Drosselmeyer’s Assistant | Thomas Thiele |
| Frau Stahlbaum | Marge Jewell |
| Herr Stahlbaum | Ron Wogen |
| Auntie | Debra Cable |
| Parents |
Sue Cullen & Eddie Escalera Tracy Olsen / Melody Houston & Bill Boone Judy Rossbach & Ray Genato Renee Roulet & Tom Zepko Kyi Kyi Win & Gregory Valladao |
| Maids |
Heather Fitzgerald Jessica Stricker |
| Clara’s Friends |
Courtney Cochran Julia Giacopuzzi Rachel Landrum Shannon Longworth Alexa Olsen Stacie Overmyer |
| Fritz’s Friends |
Max Cibelli Jack Kirkland Tristan Moss-Vasquez Mattison Solgan Thomas Thiele |
| Young Guests (Cast 1) |
Cassie Burns Heather Cummins Ashley DeClerk Jordan Klein Jacqueline Millington Haley Olsen |
| Young Guests (Cast 2) |
Cassie Burns Courtney Brooks Victoria Peterson Moriah Solgan Carly Ann Welsh Mackenzie Williams |
| Harlequin Dolls |
Hannah Drasil Amanda Gardner |
| Toy Soldier Doll | Stephen Jacobsen |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 1) |
Sydney Aaron Alexandra Lynch Victoria McJunkin Morgan Snow Rebecca Thiele Riley Weiner |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 2) |
Leah Hannum Alexandra Lynch Josie Marganian Natalie Peterson Natalie Vandel |
| Dollies (Cast 1) |
Chloe Mazakas Maddison Monical Rachel Paganini |
| Dollies (Cast 2) |
Juliana Marganian Skeetie Sales Joanna Valladao |
| Soldiers |
Matthew Alexander Austin Becker Anthony Castro, Jr. Ethan Castro Max Cibelli Caleb Eddinger Dominic W. Houston Jack Kirkland Zachary Lynch Tristan Moss-Vasquez Mattison Solgan Michael Thiele Thomas Thiele |
| The Mouse King | Ray Genato |
| Mice |
Allison Curtin Meghan DeGrave Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Lauren Fitzgerald Kassondra Marr Melina Moss-Vasquez |
| Snow Soloists |
Rosie Caldwell Erin Drasil Courtney McCormick Kelly Vento |
| Snow |
Hannah Drasil Heather Fitzgerald Amanda Gardner Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Monique Romero Jessica Stricker Danae Tetreau Katie White |
| Intermediate Snow |
Bethany Basham Madeline Goodwin Elizabeth Kirk Chelsea Magness Timmerie Millington Brianna Tait |
Act II
| Lead Angels |
Claire Metzger Darby Oleson |
| Angels |
Holly Amato Olivia Carson Ashley DeClerk Ali Goodman Madison Imus Jacqueline Millington Haley Olsen Victoria Peterson Carly Ann Welsh |
| Candy Canes |
Princess: Kelsey Marckstadt Prince: Jakob Basham Meghan DeGrave Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Brooke Henderson Rebecca Landrum Rosie McDonald |
| Sugar Plum Fairy | Ana Lobe |
| Cavalier | Ramon Thielen |
| Spanish |
Men Armando Neri Luigi de Nuñez / Gregory Valladao Ladies Erin Drasil (Lead) Heather Fitzgerald Jessica Stricker Alternate: Monique Romero |
| Chinese |
Kelly Vento Katie White Alternates: Hannah Drasil, Madeline Goodwin |
| Arabian |
Rosie Caldwell Jeremiah Tatum |
| Trepak |
Ray Genato Timmerie Millington Brianna Tait Alternate: Chelsea Magness |
| Mirlitons |
Courtney McCormick Stephen Jacobsen Alternate: Carlie Houmand |
| Bakers |
Bethany Basham Jakob Basham Julia Giacopuzzi Madeline Goodwin Amanda Hendren Elizabeth Kirk Kelsey Marckstadt Kassondra Marr Hannah McDonald Nastassja McDonald Lauren Ochs Valeria Regalado |
| Chocolates |
Holly Amato Taylor Camerena Emily Kirk Rosie McDonald Brittany Mergard Baylee Wilhelmson Alternate: Cassie Burns |
| Waltz Soloists |
Rosie Caldwell Erin Drasil Courtney McCormick Kelly Vento Stephen Jacobsen Eliezer Rabello Jeremiah Tatum |
| Waltz Flowers |
Hannah Drasil Heather Fitzgerald Amanda Gardner Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Monique Romero Jessica Stricker Danae Tetreau Katie White |
| Butterflies |
Amanda Hendren Elizabeth Kirk Chelsea Magness Kelsey Marckstadt |
| Caterpillars |
Jessica Sanford Kiley Snow (Cast 1) Joanna Valladao (Cast 2) |
| Ladybugs |
Sierra Lund Lauren Walker Emily Wysocki |
| Lilacs |
Olivia Carson Brenna Castro Renae Giacopuzzi Ali Goodman Kylie Stehmeier Melina Moss-Vasquez |
(as of 11/12/05)