Act I
| Clara | Rosie Caldwell (alternate: Máighan Perry) |
| The Nutcracker | Josh Switzer |
| Clara’s Best Friends |
Heather Fitzgerald Danae Tetreau (alternate: Máighan Perry) |
| Fritz | Jakob Basham (alternate: Zachary Lynch) |
| Herr Drosselmeyer | Jim Ferranti (alternate: Tom Zepko) |
| Frau Stahlbaum | Marge Jewell |
| Herr Stahlbaum | Ron Wogen |
| Auntie | Sandy Allen |
| Parents |
Nancy Caldwell & Russ Caldwell Sue Cullen & Eddie Escalera Diane Gonzalez & Gregory Valladao Robin Goss & Geoff Goss Tracy Olsen & Bill Boone Renee Roulet & Tom Zepko |
| Maids |
Joelle Pitts Jessica Stricker |
| Clara’s Friends |
Bethany Basham Brynna Caldwell Julia Giacopuzzi Elizabeth Kirk Rachel Landrum Timmerie Millington Brianna Tait |
| Fritz’s Friends |
Derek Alford Thomas Bennett Josh Caldwell Michael Caldwell Zachary Lynch Christian Rogers |
| Young Guests (Cast 1) |
Claire Castillo Meghan DeGrave Allison Gaddie Nina Gaw Delaney Gibson Rebecca Landrum Melina Moss-Vasquez Alexa Olsen |
| Young Guests (Cast 2) |
Claire Castillo Allison Curtin Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Rebecca Landrum Rosie McDonald Jacqueline Millington Melina Moss-Vasquez |
| Toy Soldier Dolls |
Caitlin Schmitt (alternate: Courtney McCormick) Josh Switzer |
| Harlequin Dolls |
Máighan Perry (alternate: Maggie Sievers) Stephen Jacobsen |
| Soldiers |
Derek Alford Jakob Basham Thomas Bennett Anthony Castro Max Cibelli Zachary Lynch Jon Michael Magness Tristan Moss-Vasquez Mychael Perry Reece Perry Christian Rogers |
| The Mouse King | James Perry |
| Mice |
Rachel Allen Kassandra Bennett Madeline Goodwin Keila Huss Lauren Kiveln Hannah McDonald Chelsea Magness Lauren Ochs Valeria Regalado |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 1) |
Arianna Assad Cassie Burns Kyra Gardner Angela Gaw Sophia Marano Macayla Swanson Mackenzie Williams |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 2) |
Cassie Burns Kyra Gardner Sophia Marano Alana Roszyk Brianna Sireika Macayla Swanson Joanna Valladao |
| Dollies (Cast 1) |
Haley Olsen Moriah Solgan Baylee Wilhelmson |
| Dollies (Cast 2) |
Holly Amato Rhuby Noriyuki Haley Olsen |
| Snow Soloists |
Courtney McCormick Maggie Sievers (alternate: Caitlin Schmitt) |
| Snow |
Kamalla Bennett Rosie Caldwell Erin Drasil Heather Fitzgerald Jillian O’Connor Máighan Perry Joelle Pitts Caitlin Schmitt Michelle Stebbings Jessica Stricker Danae Tetreau |
| Intermediate Snow |
Hannah Drasil Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Katie White Kate Winchell (alternate: Brianna Tait) |
Act II
| Lead Angels |
Kassondra Marr Lauren Ochs |
| Angels |
Jessica Alexander Brenna Castro Emily Curtin Morgan Freitag Emily Kirk Kelsey Marckstadt Alanna Moring Selah Parlee |
| Candy Canes |
Princess: Kate Winchell (alternate: Mackenzie McCormick) Prince: Stephen Jacobsen Miranda Ballinger Kassandra Bennett Lauren Fitzgerald Shannon Longworth Alexa Olsen Stacie Overmyer |
| Sugar Plum Fairy | Alwyn McCormick |
| Cavalier | Vincent McCloskey |
| Spanish |
Men: Armando Neri, Luigi de Nuñez Lead: Erin Lardi Jillian O’Connor Michelle Stebbings (alternates: Caitlin Schmitt, Gregory Valladao) |
| Chinese |
Kamalla Bennett Erin Drasil (alternate: Danae Tetreau) |
| Arabian |
Courtney McCormick Josh Switzer |
| Trepak |
Heather Fitzgerald Máighan Perry Stephen Jacobsen (alternates: Mindy Mink, Josh Switzer) |
| Mirlitons |
Caitlin Schmitt Maggie Sievers (alternate: Courtney McCormick) |
| Bakers |
Lead: Jordyn Switzer Rachel Allen Hannah Drasil Amanda Gardner Madeline Goodwin Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Brianna Tait Katie White Kate Winchell (alternate: Chelsea Magness) |
| Chocolates |
Courtney Cochran Meghan DeGrave Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Alexa Olsen |
| Waltz Soloists |
Courtney McCormick Maggie Sievers (alternate: Caitlin Schmitt) |
| Waltz |
Kamalla Bennett Rosie Caldwell Erin Drasil Heather Fitzgerald Jillian O’Connor Máighan Perry Caitlin Schmitt Michelle Stebbings Danae Tetreau |
| Waltz Corps |
Joelle Pitts Jessica Stricker |
| Butterflies |
Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Kate Winchell (alternate: Hannah Drasil) |
| Caterpillars |
Moriah Solgan Macayla Swanson (alternate: Brianna Sireika) |
| Ladybugs |
Holly Amato Brenna Castro Baylee Wilhelmson |
| Lilacs |
Jessica Alexander Courtney Cochran Alyson Curtin Allison Gaddie Miranda Mastro Rosie McDonald |