Act I
| Herr Drosselmeyer | Jim Ferranti (alternate: Greg Izay) |
| Drosselmeyer’s Assistant | Michael Stebbings |
| Herr Stahlbaum | Tom Zepko |
| Frau Stahlbaum | Marge Jewell |
| Clara | Maggie Sievers (alternate: Courtney McCormick) |
| Fritz | Beau Stebbings (alternate: Zachary Lynch) |
| Auntie | Sandy Allen |
| Maids |
Jessicah Cowan Caitlin Schmitt |
| Parents |
Heidi Bravo / Renee Roulet & David Gupton Nancy Caldwell & Russ Caldwell Diane Gonzalez & Gregory Valladao Dara Palmer & Daniel Palmer Vicki Stebbings & Gary Stebbings Danae Tetreau & Bill Boone |
| Clara’s Best Friends |
Rosie Caldwell Máighan Perry |
| Clara’s Friends |
Rachel Allen Ashlyn Alter Brianna Gardner Carlie Houmand Timmerie Millington Jasmine Pierik Katie White (alternate: Skye Mackay Perko) |
| Fritz’s Friends |
Jakob Basham Daniel Bravo Michael Caldwell Rene DeGrave Zachary Lynch Michael Stebbings Wesley Stebbings |
| Young Guests (Cast 1) |
Kara Cantrell Courtney Cochran Julia Giacopuzzi Elizabeth Kirk Rachel Landrum Hannah McDonald |
| Young Guests (Cast 2) |
Bethany Basham Meghan DeGrave Demi Demirkol Katalina Demirkol Elizabeth Kirk Stacie Overmyer |
| Young Guests (Cast 3) |
Bethany Basham Ashley Dillabough Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Morgan Lester Lauren Ochs |
| Harlequin Dolls |
Aerielle Wogen (alternate: Máighan Perry) Josh Switzer |
| Toy Soldier Dolls |
Keegan Guest (alternate: Rosie Caldwell) Stephen Jacobsen |
| Mice |
Kassandra Bennett Brynna Caldwell Amanda Gardner Natalie Jung Skye Mackay Perko Valeria Regalado Jordyn Switzer Brianna Tait Kate Winchell (alternate: Brianna Gardner) |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 1) |
Brenna Castro Emily Curtin Danielle Erlandson Renae Giacopuzzi Aubrey Marlar Jacqueline Millington Macayla Swanson Caitlin Thiele |
| Gingerbreads (Cast 2) |
Holly Amato Claire Castillo Nina Gaw Allie Hunter Madison Imus Haley Olsen Moriah Solgan |
| Dollies |
Rosie McDonald Alexa Olsen Kiana Rodman |
| The Nutcracker | Nathan Hynum |
| Armed Guards |
Stephen Jacobsen Michael Stebbings Gregory Valladao |
| Blue Soldiers |
Derek Alford Jakob Basham Thomas Bennett Daniel Bravo Michael Caldwell Beau Stebbings Wesley Stebbings |
| Gray Soldiers |
Joshua Caldwell Rene DeGrave Jonathan Erlandson Bryan Ford Zachary Lynch Casey Ochs Christian Rogers Thomas Thiele |
| The Mouse King | James Perry |
| Snow Soloists |
Courtney McCormick Caitlin Schmitt Michelle Stebbings Kelly Vento (alternate: Aerielle Wogen) |
| Snow |
Kamalla Bennett Rosie Caldwell Danielle Cantrell Jessicah Cowan Erin Drasil Heather Fitzgerald Keegan Guest Jillian O’Connor Máighan Perry Joelle Pitts Maggie Sievers Danae Tetreau Aerielle Wogen |
| Intermediate Snow |
Hannah Drasil Amanda Gardner Carlie Houmand Mackenzie McCormick Katie White Kate Winchell |
Act II
| Lead Angels |
Keila Huss Chelsea Magness |
| Angels |
Jessica Alexander Shelby DePry Ashley Dillabough Morgan Freitag Delaney Gibson Rebecca Landrum Hannah McDonald Melina Moss-Vasquez Skye Mackay Perko Kellie Schumake (alternate: Kara Cantrell) |
| Lead Candy Canes |
Mackenzie McCormick Stephen Jacobsen |
| Candy Canes |
Kassandra Bennett Lauren Fitzgerald Shannon Longworth Lauren Ochs Stacie Overmyer Jasmine Pierik (alternate: Elizabeth Kirk) |
| Sugar Plum Fairy | Dianna Warren |
| Cavalier | Oswaldo Muniz |
| Spanish |
Armando Neri Luigi de Nuñez Rachel Bravo Danielle Cantrell Kelly Vento (alternate: Aerielle Wogen) |
| Arabian |
Michelle Stebbings & Nathan Hynum (alternates: Courtney McCormick & Josh Switzer) |
| Chinese |
Erin Drasil Jillian O’Connor (alternate: Danae Tetreau) |
| Trepak |
Kamalla Bennett Jessicah Cowan Josh Switzer (alternate: Joelle Pitts) |
| Mirlitons |
Courtney McCormick Caitlin Schmitt (alternate: Kelly Vento) |
| Bakers |
Rachel Allen Hannah Drasil Amanda Gardner Jessica Harp Carlie Houmand Stephen Jacobsen Mackenzie McCormick Joelle Pitts Jessica Stricker Jordyn Switzer Katie White Kate Winchell |
| Waltz Soloists |
Courtney McCormick Caitlin Schmitt Kelly Vento Aerielle Wogen |
| Waltz |
Kamalla Bennett Rosie Caldwell Danielle Cantrell Jessicah Cowan Erin Drasil Keegan Guest Jillian O’Connor Máighan Perry Maggie Sievers Michelle Stebbings |
| Butterflies |
Heather Fitzgerald Joelle Pitts |
| Lilacs |
Courtney Cochran Katherine Eddinger Kimberly Eddinger Morgan Lester Rachel Lowson Darby Oleson |
| Ladybugs |
Claire Castillo Renae Giacopuzzi Jacqueline Millington |
| Caterpillars (Cast 1) |
Aubrey Marlar Alexa Olsen |
| Caterpillars (Cast 2) |
Nina Gaw Alexa Olsen |